Friday, April 15, 2016

Media (is) the message?

Clark vs Kozma

As I read the debate among both arguments it was interesting to read the importance of education from a teachers view point.

Teachers cannot apply any means of technology first. In order for students to grasp any concept, the educational lesson needs to take place such as scaffolding, vocabulary, topic, comprehension questions and the pedagogy needs to be established first. After much thought I am siding with Clark’s argument in stating that technology is clearly a vehicle to an understanding.
As a teacher I cannot begin a lesson with a technology tool. Students would merely stare and connect any prior learning to the video or technology use.
Students need to acquire a good background in order to watch, view or interact with any technology tool. "Further, I claimed, that any necessary teaching method could be designed into a variety of media presentations." (Clark)
Yes, technology does make a lesson more interesting and it does require knowledge along with a good chance of storing data in long term memory, but as a first tool it does not.
The intelligence needs to be established in order to include any technology device.
Once the learnings are established any form of technology will become a better significance to the lesson or topic at hand.

Kozma’s theory in my view cannot take place without the 
foundation, core learning of any learning. Yes, "Data searching is by no means limited to the computer, although the computer is often faster and more efficient." (Morrison) the importance of further searching had to require the introduction of a concept or lesson first.

From my own personal experience I have introduced lessons with a video or some type of media and my student’s grasp of learning the concept was very vague.
I found myself reintroducing the media after my lesson and it was then that my teachings were connecting to the media used.
Overall, Clark has a great point no matter what lesson is being taught scaffolding our learners first through the pedagogy of a lesson works best than introducing a source of technology/ media first.  


Clark, R. E. (1994). Media will never influence learning. Educational Technology Research & Development, 42(2), 21-29. doi:10.1007/BF02299088

Morrison, G. R. (1994). The Media Effects Question: "Unresolvable" or Asking the Right Question. Educational Technology, Research And Development, 42(2), 41-44.

5 comments:

  1. I read in articles over and over that a good teacher is a good teacher and if she uses technology in her lessons that it will make an impact on her student. Technology is only a tool.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting points. I leaned more towards Kozma, but Clark did make some wonderful points. The key to learning is an excellent teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post and I do see what you mean but I don't agree entirely. I have also started lessons with media and it seems to spark a connection and an interests so much more. Even if students don't fully understand the concept at first, media provides a way to get interested in a new concept and may even provide the background knowledge too. I've often used it as a spring board to see what they knew and ask questions about what they saw, how it made them feel, if they had ever experienced anything similar, and what they learned from the video. While I still believe it is our job as teachers to make sure students are understanding concepts especially with critical thinking, discussions and higher order questioning, I don't believe that using media and technology first is such a bad thing.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I find that when a student has had prior learnings, technology usage first does indeed spark interest and they get excited, but when there is no prior knowledge, the students simple gets hooked to learn more about it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This was a great post and points up the fact that experienced, engaged, and motivated teachers provide the best learning environments so that students can succeed. No matter what tools they use~

    ReplyDelete